As I was struggling to rank my top albums of 2008, I read Roger Ebert’s top twenty films of 2008 where, finally giving up winnowing his choices down to just ten, he wrote:

If you must have a Top 10 List, find a coin in your pocket. Heads, the odd-numbered movies are your 10. Tails, the even-numbered.

This served as a moment of inspiration. Rather than ordering twenty albums, I thought, I would put them into two tiers and then write a bit of code to randomize their ordering within the tiers with each page refresh.

Perhaps luckily for my readers, in the end I decided against this. As I started to write my little blurbs, momentary preferences started to sink in. But I admit they are just that: momentary preferences. I still like my number one album from last year, but man that Spoon album, which I ranked #16, sure has been getting a lot of play this year.

So here it is: a snapshot of what I currently think are my top twenty albums of 2008. Last year, some of the recommendations in the comments became new favorites, so please tell me where I went astray.

20. Kanye West – 808s & Heartbreak

When I heard the first singles coming from this percussively stripped-down and AutoTune-obsessed breakup album, I was expecting throwaway tracks, some filler before his next proper album. But it turns out that this is a proper album, with only the live freestyle on the final track meriting the skip button. It isn’t quite Kanye at his finest, but it just goes to show that we all benefit by his persistent sincerity.

Favorite tracks: Paranoid; RoboCop

19. El Guincho – Alegranza

Yes, it sounds like it was produced in exactly the same way as an Animal Collective album, but on Alegranza the loop components come almost strictly from the tropical realm (think steel drums and maracas). But it’s never exhausting in the way Animal Collective can be, and it’s surprisingly danceable throughout.

Favorite tracks: Antillas; Fata Morgana

18. Coldplay – Viva la Vida

While I’ve always had a guilty pleasure like of Coldplay’s singles, their past albums have been filled with aimless, tiresome songs. On Viva la Vida, they still wear their influences on their sleeves (along with colored ribbons), but the songs are rarely boring and benefit from Brian Eno’s light touch.

Favorite tracks: 42; Death and All His Friends

17. Gang Gang Dance – Saint Dymphna

How to describe this eclectic album? I could say Pure Moods meets Battles, but that really only describes a few tracks on here, and doesn’t manage to explain the electronic touches or dancefloor moments. I guess I’ll give up and say this is the best compilation album of 2008 by one band.

Favorite tracks: First Communion; House Jam

16. Hercules and Love Affair – Hercules and Love Affair

Yes, 2008 was the breakout year of new-wave/disco (see also Cut Copy’s In Ghost Colours). And it’s not even “retro-influenced” anymore – much of this album sounds straight out of the 70’s, with the exception of Antony’s voice, which has finally found a comfortable home. It started with the Junior Boys a few years ago, but I’ve been a sucker for this stuff ever since.

Favorite tracks: Hercules Theme; Blind